A federal judge ruled in March that an illegal immigrant who was being held in custody in San Diego died as a result of denial of medical treatment, and that this was “beyond cruel and unusual punishment.” Francisco Castaneda, 36, was placed in immigration custody after serving an eight month prison term in 2005 for possession of methamphetamine with intent to distribute.
While in custody, he began to complain of a growing, painful lesion on his penis. According to government records, during Castaneda’s 11 month detention, he was given pills to deal with the pain, but the lesion was never biopsied, though this had been recommended by several doctors. However, one doctor at the Division of Immigration Health Services said the agency thought of the removal of the lesion “an elective outpatient procedure” and would not admit Castaneda. Castaneda was released last year, but died in February of metastatic squamous cell carcinoma.
Squamous Cell Carcinoma
Squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) is one of the most common forms of skin cancer usually affecting sun-exposed skin of middle-aged or elderly people. In geographic areas where there is a high amount of sun exposure, SCC is even more common. While most SCCs can be removed easily by a physician, and is thought of as a minor surgical procedure, larger areas may require radiation therapy and “aggressive surgical management.” Those who have a high risk of getting SCC also have a higher chance that it will metastasize and require careful monitoring.
Admission of Fault
Last week, the federal government acknowledged it was at fault for Castaneda’s death due to refusing him treatment. His family filed a lawsuit for medical negligence, which the government agrees with. An attorney for the Castaneda family said, “The United States’ admission of liability is a recognition that they have no defense…for medical negligence and wrongful death.” The maximum damages carried by the claim are $250,000.
Because this country is polarized on illegal immigrants, especially illegal immigrants who are imprisoned for drug dealing or possession, it is easy to forget that they are also people who deserve the right to see a doctor when they are sick. Denying them this basic right does not make us a better, stronger nation. If anything, it shows us as a scared, xenophobic, and uncaring people who would rather see people like Francisco Castaneda die than show them compassion. Even the government admits it was wrong in this case.
If you have lost a loved one due to medical negligence, please contact an injury lawyer with experience in the fields of medical malpractice and wrongful death.
